Sick and tired of misguided notions about Cape Bretoners.

I am beyond sick and tired of the misguided notion that Cape Bretoners are “whiners, welfare recipients and a drain on the Province.

Fact: The Provincial Government uses the economic disparity in Cape Breton and rural Nova Scotia to garner as much of the Equalization transfer as possible.

Fact: The intended purpose of this transfer is to alleviate economic disparity in these communities (Cape Breton and rural Nova Scotia)

Fact: 26% of this 1.94 billion (Aprox. $500 million) is provided for the economic disparity among these communities.

Fact: The province distributes only $30.5 million.

Fact: HRM is entitled to 0% of this equalization transfer.

Fact: You cannot severely underfund all these communities for 20 years and expect that we will somehow thrive and prosper.

It has become abundantly clear that our continued poverty maintains the current “have-not” status of our province.

I am NOT whining. I am NOT looking for a hand out. I am NOT on welfare. I AM a hard working, overly taxed Cape Bretoner who would like the opportunity to live and work outside of the “Almighty HRM” and have a comparable standard of living, taxation, infrastructure, etc. I have no desire to follow Bridgetown, Canso, Parrsboro or Springhill into dissolution.

It is long past time that ALL Nova Scotians got informed and educated on the spending habits and LACK of distribution of the provincial monies. I would like to dispel the MYTH that Cape Breton is somehow a “Drain” on provincial money when, in actual fact, Cape Breton brings in 29% ($3.29 billion) on the total budget!

I AM OUTRAGED!!!!!!

I am ashamed of my fellow Nova Scotians who think so poorly of us. We did not generate this fiscal disparity but have been forced to endure it for more than 20 years. If you want to understand how we, in Cape Breton feel, I will paint you a picture.

PRETEND Sydney is the Capital of Nova Scotia. All federal transfers for the provinces yearly budget come to Sydney. We will misappropriate as much money as we want and build Cape Breton up to “Shangri-La 2.0” while severely underfunding mainland Nova Scotia. We will control your hospitals, your schools, taxes, infrastructure, social services, administration, EVERYTHING!!! We will grow and prosper at an accelerated rate while the rest of the province declines and slowly, oh so slowly, bleeds to death. Towns dissolve and 1000 people a year leave the mainland. As you plead with us to treat you fairly and equally, we will then accuse you of being whiners and welfare recipients, of always looking for a handout, being lazy, miss managers, authors of your own doom. Although this picture in just PRETEND for the HRM, it is REALITY for the residents of Cape Breton and rural Nova Scotia.

It has become increasingly difficult, almost impossible in fact, to want to be part of a province that views us and our First Nations Neighbors with such contempt, who speak out against us with a litany of derogatory commentary and underfunds us to poverty. If you look closely, you will see the truth of the situation is this, the HRM PROSPERS from Cape Breaton’s poverty by the BILLIONS.

As Senator Dan Christmas stated, “it is time to start the conversation” for independence and self governance separate from the province. Although the mainland Nova Scotia might think that sounds great, the provincial government will fight against it. They have a 20 year addiction to our money, usurping it, using it however they want and answering to nobody. It wouldn’t take long for Nova Scotians to come to the realization that Cape Breton wasn’t the problem after all. All we ever wanted was to be treated EQUALLY and FAIRLY. Instead we have received ridicule and scorn for trying to stand up for ourselves.

I am ashamed of our politicians who, for 20 years, have refused to stand up and represent their voters. This issue should have been rectified a long time ago. In any other capacity these politicians would have been fired for not doing what they are paid to do. Instead, they will get a pension, a pat on the head and a job well done.

WHAT A PILE OF CRAP!!

Brenda Matheson
Sydney

Posted by
Receive news by email and share your news and events for free on goCapeBreton.com
SHOW ME HOW


45,054 62
https://capebreton.lokol.me/sick-and-tired-of-misguided-notions-about-cape-bretoners
Gov Political Commentary

62

Log In or Sign Up to add a comment.
Depth
S Green Follow Me
Well done Brenda. You could not have said it better. Way to go. I hope every person in HRM reads this because it is all true. Good job.
dave finlay Follow Me
Hey, Brenda well said what I think we need is a march we need everyone and I mean everyone in Cape Breton to arrive in Halifax for one day completely lockup the bridges. Strangle their city as they have done to us
Charles Sampson Follow Me
Brenda, great letter. Transferring these equalization payments unconditionally is NOT provided for in the Constitution Act, 1982. It is time the Liberal McNeil government acted on his party’s AGM RESOLUTION that called for an audit of these equalization payments after being received by Nova Scotia. The government has something to hide and an audit will expose that.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Thank you Charlie. I watched our councilors on Tuesday in session.They wanted to know what the status was on a motion they passed in February concerning their request for an audit. Would you believe the Mayor forgot to send it ?I would. It's only May !
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Hello Dave, I'm not much of a militant but I would ask you to join our meeting at New Dawn (former Holy Angels High) Monday,May 7 as we finalize our planned protest
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
6pm to 8pm
jane lynne hooper Follow Me
i will be there
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Feel free to bring friends & neighbors.Spread the word,we protest Wednesday,May 9, 4 to 6,in front of the Provincial Building
jane lynne hooper Follow Me
time for loud voices and change
S Green Follow Me
Brenda. I hope your going to email this letter to every politician in the province. This letter should be viewed by all of them. Tammy Martin can't be the only politician on this island who willing to speak up for us prior to our death as a community. Who is your MLA where you live? Definitely send it to whoever it is.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Unfortunately,my MLA is Derek Mombourquette. I emailed him over a month ago and he hasn't responded . It is that deafening silence I have grown accustomed to from our REPRESENTATIVES who choose NOT to represent us. At least with this format he might actually hear me. The truth is they really do hear us but they CHOOSE to ignore us and hope we will shut up and go away. Sorry boys & girls,not this time.My voice will just have to get LOUDER!!!!
S Green Follow Me
Oh. I'm so sorry. About that. Derek is the Minister of Municipal Affairs and he a Geoff MacLellan are both minister's that could actually do something about this but choose not to. They both are misirable failures for Cape Breton. That will change at election time.
Barbara LeLievre Follow Me
S. Green, sadly that change was expected during the last election.....given their lack of loyalty to the teachers.......but it didn't happen. People are fickle.....if it doesn't affect them directly, they don't care. These are two very popular MLA's amongst their community citizens......
Cora MacNeil Follow Me
And when he does, it'll be a copy and pasted approved letter. Not worth them time to read. Manipulative and misleading. That's what you'll get. Even still, it doesn't hurt to send follow up. They are living off our tax dollars after all.
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
They are ALL the same! I'm so sick of it all.
donald macdonald Follow Me
Brenda I Live far away from my home but you are so right on your article and it should be read my every single person in nove Scotia thank you
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
I hope we can make a positive change in our future here in Cape Breton and enable you to return.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Brenda, thank you for this perspective. We, the Cape Breton United Party Party share your view. Your article was shared among our members. We would truly welcome a person of your apparent knowledge. Please join our movement: https://capebreton.lokol.me/open-invitation-to-cape-breton-mlas The time is now if we are to reclaim our future and our dignity.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Thank you for you words of encouragement, Christian. Unfortunately, my faith in ANY political party is nil to none. I'm more interested in coming together as an independent ,self-governed Island of people power than political power.At heart I am a passivist. Your very logo with its fist in my face doesn't generate a positive feel. I know your intentions and motivation are aimed in the right direction but I'm not interested in Party Politics.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
I appreciate your position and we are pushing towards some form of autonmy, the logo represents strength; strength in numbers, strenght in conviction and strength in unity. A Ghandi style insurgency....we are on the same side and regarless, we appreciate and respect your words. Please keep up the good work.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Hi Brenda, you're part of the NSEF planning committee for the up coming protest. WOW! This is great work you folks are doing......if onlly the Cape Breton United Party could attract 1,000 passavists like you! Keep it going and we support you!
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Hello again Christian. First and foremost I am a life time resident and concerned citizen of this beautiful island and its marvelous people. My post was prompted by thoughtless comments that made my blood boil but without the diligent work and commitment from the NSEF for the past 20 years, I too would be uneducated on the truth and facts of this matter.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
P.S. Assembling signs as we speak .
Christian Murphy Follow Me
I recently read an email sent to the Auditor General from Tory member Keith Bain....I learned that the NSEF has been lobying the Auditor General for some time.....I sincerely hope this doesn't result in the PCs and Cecil Clarke attempting to take credit for the incredible work of the NSEF!
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
No fear of Cecil Clarke attempting to take credit. His council passed a motion in Feb.for an audit. I watched the session on Tuesday and when he was asked about the status of this PASSED motion, oops! his bad. It was still on his desk!!!!! This is only May after all.By the way,when he announced for the P.C.Party leadership,he never mentioned he was the mayor of CBRM,he never mentioned Cape Breton at all ..But what he did say was he would support Halifax to become the economic hub of Atlantic Canada.What does that sound like to you?
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Please feel free to join our march Wednesday, May 9 on Prince Street in front of the provincial building 4pm to 6pm..This would be a wonderful way to show your support.Bring all your friends & CBUP members. All are welcome with open arms !
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
WTG!!!! We need this! Hoping to be there also!
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Lynn,please come and bring ALL your friends!!!!
[comment deleted] Posted
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
I don' think so Cora. It was in the CapeBreton Post today and I'm sure there will be something soon
Suzanne Dickey Follow Me
Well said Brenda. My husband and I live near St. Peter's but are planning to join this march.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
Thank you Suzanne. This is an opportunity for our voices to be SEEN. Feel free to bring a friend or 10.LOL
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
Thank You. Well said
Bill Brown Follow Me
I applaud the initiative. I would (and have been trying) to move back to CB in a heartbeat if the jobs were there. Yes, the unequal transfer payments are a hindrance. But you also need to look at other factors that push people away. There are more Gov't jobs on the mainland. The property tax rate in Sydney is surprisingly more than other places. Healthcare! I know that one can be linked to the other but those ARE factors. If self identifying as a province will help heal the bleed, then start the campaign. If you need a bilingual professional to run as an MP (moved back to CB, of course), then I will throw my hat in the ring. I queried Costco last year of they would put a store in Sydney. I explained that there are @ 100,000 resident within an hours drive. Their answer was simply put, NO! I am a firm believer that God helps those who help themselves. Start the process. I'm in! Just for giggles, have a look at the response that the Farmer's Daughter got when they offered free land for a job. Why not make that part of your plight. I think that you might not be able to keep up with the demand!
Cora MacNeil Follow Me
I found the piece from tje CB post last evening. I shared it.
Lorna MacNeil Follow Me
Yikes. The debate around equalization payments and Cape Breton is important, but the tone of many of these comments is deeply unhelpful.
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
Hi Lorna MacNeil..can you explain that please. WE NEED to stand up and make ourselves heard which hasn't been done, ever- here in Cape Breton. I'm ALL for it, but, I'm uncertain as to what you mean by the 'tone' of the comments..
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
You Nailed it Brenda Matherson!!! Thank you.
Charles Sampson Follow Me
Thanks Brenda. All the politicians have to do is an audit, which will prove you are correct about this ripoff. But that is why an audit will NOT be done!
Lynn Hussey Follow Me
Exactly!!!!
Charles Sampson Follow Me
Thanks Brenda for your excellent comment describing how the federal Equalization payments have been manipulated by ALL political parties that have formed government. I hope people are following, too, John Whalley’s suit against the CBRM for being politically removed from his long-held responsibilities is yet another example of the obstacles that have prevented this municipality from economically being a part of this province’s development. John Whalley as a former highly-qualified employee of the CBRM, represented this municipality in its Equalization struggle for justice far better than the highly-paid politicians who have remained silent all these years. His article of a few years ago in the CB POST clearly explained the federal government provides approximately 26% OF THE TOTAL EQUALIZATION PAYMENTS because of the municipal deficiency in their fiscal capacity related to property. As I recall, he received a formal rebuke on his employee file for informing the public of this important information. So much for freedom of speech! It is sad we don’t have more people in our corrupt political system with the integrity and professionalism shown by John Whalley.
Blair Gushue Follow Me
John Whalley, a smart young man with CBRM's best interest at heart. It's too bad in this day and age you can't questioned how things are done! If your not in agreement, your bullied and squeezed out of the picture. Sounds like our equalization issue!
Ron Evely Follow Me
100% Brenda!!! If only our local politicians- municipal, provincial and federal - would actually get on board with the people they are overpaid to represent and do something about this equalization mess. Do the RIGHT THING! That’s where the leadership should be. John Morgan tried to get trackson with the equalization issue and was “on his own”...except for local citizens support. Cape Breton should separate. Why not? What’s the point, what’s the advantage to staying under the boot of Halifax? Then we would get our equalization transfers directly from Ottawa, as intended. We would then be able to lessen the tax burden on ourselves - provincial income taxes and property taxes.
The people of Cape Breton and rural Nova Scotia are getting educated about this situation that Brenda articulated so well in her letter. He NSEF will be out in full force this spring and summer, educating people about the lack of support, communications and cooperation from the very politicians we pay to look after out interests. Mark Eyking and Rodger Cuzner should hang their heads in shame for what has become of Cape Breton along with many of the long serving MLA's. The political party system in this country is broken and we are living proof here in Cape Breton. Just so the public is aware....All we are asking from our 2 Mp's here is to get us a meeting in Ottawa about thus but they refuse to assist us. It is not like we are asking them to do their jobs or anything, we will do that for them but we need to speak to the Finance and Justice Ministers and after hundreds of requests, they still ignore us. When did the politicians forget that they work for the people who elected them and not their party. The people's taxes pay their salaries but they will only show concern at election time. Don't be fooled Cape Breton. It is time for complete change on this Island and you will see the same thing happen in the south Shore and Annopilis Valley Regions. The Nova Scotia Government has to be the most corrupt in this country and we, the people, need to fix that and soon.
Kel donovan Follow Me
The reason P.E.I. became a province/ It was specially treated after a meeting was held there at one point on the idea of Canada becoming a country.We have much more history to fall back on,more tourist attraction and a lot more culture.Nothing against P.E.I,but if that part can become a province we need men and women in the mainland lesgislature to stand up for Cape Breton becoming a province.Right at the moment i hear nothing from these parties or members from Cape Breton that supposedly represent us.We need a voice.a loud voice.We need more people like you Brenda.Thank you!
Blair Gushue Follow Me
Obvious Brenda has a passion for Cape Breton. This is something we all need. Did you ever hear the saying: "History repeats itself". If you look back in CB history late 1700's early 1800's. N.S. prevented CB from keeping its taxes, prevented population growth and finally when CB was in danger of economic collapse it annexed the island without consent of the people. We were always meant to be in control of our own future but never given the chance.
Joe Ward Follow Me
Having only recently read about a more in-depth history of Cape Breton, I was astounded by how many parallels there were politically and economically from our very beginnings until the present day. A pattern is repeating itself.
Brenda Matheson My Post Follow Me
The most recent "rape & pillage" of our tax revenue comes from our cannabis sales. The province claims it's COMPLICATED to figure out just how much of the profit from our 1 single outlet here in Cape Breton should come back to us. The government would like to keep it all but I'm sure they will find a way to keep the lions share as they have done with the Equalization transfer, gas tax,HST,GST and NSPI property tax. I almost forgot.The provincial government receives a Service transfer from the federal government to cover a multitude of items including schools and corrections.They then required the CBRM to pay service charges on schools & correction to the tune of millions! Can you say DOUBLE-DIPPING !!!
Parker Donham Follow Me
Readers of Brenda's post should follow this helpful rule: Every sentence she begins with, "FACT" is followed by a provable falsehood. Kirk O'Connell is correct: Her post is a pastiche of misinformation typical of the claptrap peddled by the Equalization Fairness crowd. These falsehoods have been repeatedly exposed. and disproven, but that never deters Matheson and Al Maroun from repeating them. The federal equalization grant is not and never was intended to be transferred to municipal governments, not in this province, not in any province. That notion is a lie promulgated by the Equalization Fairness crowd. Federal Equalization is intended to subsidize programs like education and health care to bring them up to a National standard. That's exactly what it does. It support schools, hospitals, doctors fees, School bus systems, throughout the province including Cape Breton. The province's municipal equalization program is intended to assist municipalities like CBRM, that have a lower than average tax base, to provide local municipal services at an acceptable level. For as long as the program has existed, CBRM has received close to half the entire fund, more than half in some years. The municipal Equalization fund has been unchanged for many years. Like many, I believe it should be increased. But confusing it with Federal Equalization, and portraying Cape Bretoners as victims dating back hundreds of years of some massive conspiracy to deprive us of our rights, is a Big Lie that disgusts voters outside CBRM, and sets back the case for reforming municipal Equalization. A reader could reasonably ask, "Why do Al Maroun and the others keep lying about this?"
the Constitution of Canada states the intended purpose of this program is: (1) Without altering the legislative authority of Parliament or of the provincial legislatures, or the rights of any of them with respect to the exercise of their legislative authority, Parliament and the legislatures, together with the government of Canada and the provincial governments, are committed to (a) promoting equal opportunities for the well-being of Canadians; (b) furthering economic development to reduce disparity in opportunities; and (c) providing essential public services of reasonable quality to all Canadians. Marginal note: Commitment respecting public services (2) Parliament and the government of Canada are committed to the principle of making equalization payments to ensure that provincial governments have sufficient revenues to provide reasonably comparable levels of public services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation. (98) We receive $15 million and pay back $19 million.
Parker Donham Follow Me
Yeah. I've read the Constitution. Please look at the words you quoted: "Parliament and the government of Canada are committed to the principle of making equalization payments to ensure that PROVINCIAL governments have sufficient revenues to provide reasonably comparable levels of public services at reasonably comparable levels of taxation." PROVINCIAL governments must be able to provide reasonably comfortable levels of service. And what services do provincial governments supply? Well, the big ones are Health Care, education, higher education, roads and bridges, and community services. Who do you suppose pays for hospitals, schools, highways, etc. in Cape Breton? The provincial government does, that's who. it spends hundreds of millions of dollars here every year. We don't get only $19 million per year. That's a flat-out lie. You know it's a lie. Why do you keep repeating it?
Joe Ward Follow Me
The services aren't reasonably comparable, nor are the levels of taxation. Although the province certainly spends a lot of money here, on a previous occasion, you suggested it would be too big of a challenge to figure out how much is actually spent here. To be objective, your premise would need to support that data being determined and shared. Keep in mind, we still pay provincial, federal incomes taxes, HST, and other provincial fees too.
Parker Donham Follow Me
If what you say is true, why do the equalization fairness folks constantly repeat the lie that we only received 19 million dollars from the province? You no this is not true? Why don't you ever say so? Are you so deeply committed to the victim narrative that you can't admit to the truth? If what you say is true, then why do the equalization fairness crew constantly conflate the constitutional requirement for federal Equalization to the provinces and the provincial program to assist have not municipalities? They are two different things. You know they are two different things. Why do you keep pretending they are not?
Lloyd Allan MacPherson Follow Me
Parker, I don't believe the NSEF is repeating a lie - they seem to be 'informing' the public with the information being provided to them by government (when government seems to be cooperative). The NSEF have been friendly, generous with their time and have helped a lot of us understand at least the challenges we face in rural areas when politicians are uncooperative. They have an incredible range of skills, like most people in Cape Breton. Based on our Cape Breton roots, we feel we can do anything, make anything, fix anything - we can get out of pretty much any scrape we get ourselves in. I come from a family of 'fixers' - well known in these parts - we drive a pretty high standard in being able to fashion solutions to common everyday problems - a family of polymaths (my grandmother 'The Queen of the Highlands' as they once called her, one of the most well known). For some reason, no matter how much time I put into this local issue, I can't help but continue see a repeated example of it played out in rural areas nationwide, no matter the province or their equalization situation. It has gotten so bad in a certain areas in Ontario that one mayor has adopted a municipal charter engineered in South Africa designed to take down the 'global banking cartel'. Imagine that. He was tired of seeing youth out-migrate and is now taking economic matters into his own hands. We'll eventually get to where we need to be through collaboration and this is a fine collaborative movement that is shaping up here. There is a lot of positive energy there but please don't question the idea that our 'house is on fire'. We need all hands on deck to put this one out.
Stop putting words in our mouths. We did not say that we only get the $15 million per year. We are aware of the provincially funded programs that the province funds to the whole province. That is not what we are saying. We receive only $15 from the provincial program that is grossly inadequate and capped at $30 million and it should be in the tune of $500 million. This is the fund that is supposed to help with economic disparity. Get you facts right and stop putting words in our mouths. WHEN are you available for a public debate?
Blair Gushue Follow Me
It’s sad to see as a province we are not united. Equalization in prosperity is certainly not the case in different areas of Nova Scotia. Our government commends itself for the job well done in areas of economic growth, population increase, lower taxes, below average unemployment and a bright future. In reality it is describing mainly the provincial capital. Some may think of it as a type of Camelot. This area represents 44% of the population. Unfortunately, in the remaining majority ( 56%),in some areas such as Cape Breton there has been completely the opposite trend. You cannot hide the facts that for the last twenty five years Cape Breton has not been part of Nova Scotia’s prosperity. Population decline, double- digit unemployment, alarming tax rates, this is not what the average Nova Scotian sees as a bright future. Sooner or later people start to ask, why is this happening? What I don’t understand, is when concern citizens start to question the status quo, rather than champion their concerns, elite highly intellectual individuals appear out of nowhere using Trump like tactics, calling people liars, accusing them of skewed information and a painting a picture they got it wrong. Something like fake news! Our economic woes need to be addressed sooner than later and we need everyone to contribute in some way. What’s the point of having a democracy, if our elected officials cannot do anything to improve our economic and social well-being? Nice to see groups like NSEF ask questions!
Thank you Blair. That means alot. We see thousands of comments and every now and then we see people try to discredit us for a politician or maybe someone who is just controversial in nature. For every 1 negative comment we see 600 positive comments. All the government had to do is sit down and discuss this publically with us but they refuse and that is a major problem. Thanks for your comments and we will continue to work hard to force change. We have no choice.
We do not appreciate you calling us liars Mr. Barrs Donham. Who do you think you are? The NSEF has been studying this for over 2 decades and you think YOU are an authority. Arrogant Much???? The NSEF would like to invite you to publicly debate this issue with us so please provide a time when you are available, we would like to have the opportunity to publicly educate you and your political buddies (who you speak for ) about our thoughts and views on the Equalization issue. The Nova Scotia Provincial Government in fact does not give us any "Equalization" money. They take from us our HST, GST, Gas Tax, Nova Scotia Power Property Taxes, etc, etc. then they give us a little of our money back and call it Equalization/Town Foundation Grant to confuse us and obviously you. Politicians and people like you are the ones confusing the two programs. We get $15 million from the P R O V I N C I A L program of $30 million and that has nothing to do with the F E D E R A L program of $2 billion. In fact 26.8% of the F E D E R A L program is provided because of the weakness in fiscal tax capacity so why is it not provided to the areas that make up that weakness? I will post the confirmation of that 26.8 % here but you will probably call a former Finance Minister a liar as well.....
NOVA SCOTIA Finance Office of the Minister REF: FIN-2012-0352 Mar. 8, 2013 Mr. Charies Sampson 42 Hayden Road Sydney Forks, Nova Scotia B1L 1A2 Dear Mr. Sampson: Thank you for your recent letter regarding Nova Scotia’s property tax and miscellaneous revenues fiscal capacity within the federal Equalization program. Deficiencies in fiscal capacity related to property tax and miscellaneous revenues form a significant part of the total Equalization program in most receiving provinces. At 26.8 per cent in 2011-12, Nova Scotia’s fiscal capacity deficiency related to property tax and miscellaneous revenues is comparable to that of the other receiving provinces. However, it is important to note that this calculation is only pertinent to the determination of the total federal Equalization payment. Nova Scotia’s federal Equalization payment is an unconditional payment that has no bearing on how the Province distributes grants to its municipalities. To be clear, there is no connection between the federal Equalization payment made to Nova Scotia, as determined in the Federal-Provincial Fiscal Arrangement Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. F-8), and the equalization grants provided by Nova Scotia to its municipalities, as determined by the Municipalities Grants Act. R.S.N.S., c. 302, s. 1. As for your request for a meeting, while | am happy to meet with any group who requests an opportunity to discuss matters for which my department has responsibility, | respectfully suggest the issues you wish to discuss would best be raised with my colleague, the Honourable John MacDonell, Minister of Service Nova Scotia and Municipal Relations (SNSMR). Yours truly, Maureen MacDonald I ask you Mr. Barrs Donham? Why does the Federal Government provide 26.8% of this because of a weakness and then the provincial government does not apply this amount for the reason it was provided?
Joe Ward Follow Me
Pointing out that the CBRM receives about half of the provincial Equalization transfer adds no value to the discussion. It receives half based on the size of its population, and its need, even under the flawed provincial formula. Likewise, even if getting half mattered, it's the size of the allocation that determines whether *any* fractional allocation is sufficient. You could get 100% and still be underfunded. The Federal government has to give the province of NS a couple of billion to get by, but somehow the suggestion is that despite needing a couple billion to stay afloat, they have their own money (around $32 Million) to give to municipalities and we shouldn't believe that that money comes out of the $2 Billion. Despite the provincial transfer being called "Equalization", funded by it, and mirroring the federal program structure, we're still supposed to buy into full disassociation? Absurd. Grandma sees her grandson and 3 friends playing on the street. Calls him in. Gives him $20 and says: "The hotdog vendor will arrive soon. Make sure you and your friends have lunch". The boy excitedly goes back to his friends and tells them his grandmother gave him money for the hotdog vendor. When the vendor arrives, he buys a hotdog and pop and fries for himself, and a large fries and one pop for his friends to split. Despite that not quite being what grandma intended, the others are appreciative, "Your grandma is so awesome!" The boy says "What do you mean grandma? I bought you guys your lunch with my own money!"
Nailed it Joe. That is exactly what is happening. The Federal Government provides 26.8% of the transfer to help the "HAVE NOT" regions with their economic disparity. This province keeps it all in a "HAVE' municipality and spends it on luxury items for HRM and they have admitted so in the paper recently. The 26.8% of the total F E D E R A L transfer should be used for the reason it was provided in the first place. There is nothing equal or fair about how this province treats anyone outside the provincial capital. Why are our taxes (Commercial and Residential) through the roof when the feds provide funding every year to lower them to the rest of the province and country. Thanks Joe
Charles Sampson Follow Me
Parker Perhaps you can tell us the former finance minister Maureen MacDonald is a liar when she wrote the following: “Deficiencies in fiscal capacity related to property tax and miscellaneous revenues form a significant part of the total Equalization program in most receiving provinces. At 26.8 per cent in 2011-12, Nova Scotia’s fiscal capacity deficiency related to property tax and miscellaneous revenues is comparable to that of the otherreceiving provinces.” Her letter was dated March 8, 2013. The file is REF: FIN-2012-0352 This information was later backed up by an official in the federal finance dept. You can verify this yourself by contacting the two levels of government youself. If this amount of yearly federal funding is specifically generated because of this municipal deficiency in tax capacity related to property, where has it spent each year?
Christine Bonnar Follow Me
Brenda, that was the most powerful letter I have read thus far. You could not of made anymore truer statements and yes it is time that HRM to understand of what we are going through here in CB. You know, one thing I have noticed is how the CBC never mentions the state of affairs we are in with our healthcare at the regional hospital, or the condition we are in here with everything....it is all geared around them in Halifax so I guess that explains for some of it why they are so rude with their comments. It is because they are very uneducated about how equalization works and how bad of a situation is here. I guess it’s hard for them to understand as people don’t realize how bad something is until it affect you personally. So all we can do is keep putting it out there and eventually they will hear us and understand.
[comment deleted] Posted
seek-warrow-w
  • 1
arrow-eseek-e1 - 23 of 23 items

Facebook Comments

View all the LATEST
and HOTTEST posts
View

Share this comment by copying the direct link.

  • Our Sponsors

Using this website is subject to the Terms of Use that contain binding contractual terms.