Rankin MacSween: Did You Know We Pay Double Tax in the CBRM?

When your vote helps elect Rankin MacSween as the new mayor of the CBRM - 2 months from now in October 2016 - there will be several important reasons. Here's one that is vital to our future.

For starters, he's able to communicate some basic math that matters to every member of the Cape Breton Regional Municipality. But, first, did you know the following?

The CBRM is the Highest Taxed in ALL of Nova Scotia

Cecil Clarke recently promised that he was not going to increase the tax rates. Now pause to think of what that actually means. That is only something that will impress you if you didn't already know you live in the highest taxed municipality in all of Nova Scotia.

When you are the highest taxed municipality in all of Nova Scotia, you certainly hope things aren't going to get even worse.

Not increasing CBRM's highest taxes is like being told you have lung cancer, but it won't go to your brain. It's not the same thing as getting better. It doesn't improve your wellbeing.

Do you feel like you get the same level of service as Halifax?

One thing is for sure. You pay more for your home than those who live in an area of rural Halifax similar to your own. It's not fair, and it's a part of the reason the CBRM loses what some estimate to be 1,000 people every year.

The CBRM is helping to drive them out with our tax rates. They have to pay more with little to show for it. And it gives them (or us) another reason to finally give up and leave.

Rankin Has Some Quick and Easy "Flatbed Truck" Math That You Have to Know

You can watch the video of Rankin speaking about the tax rates. It's just over 3 minutes in length. If you don't have time, I'll summarize the comparisons he gave in some quick tables below. This isn't dull math, or difficult math. But it affects your life.

Share with: https://youtu.be/npDnWlGoMzM

CBRM Residential Housing Tax Comparison

Rankin asked us to think about a home valued at $100,000 in rural CBRM. Then he compared the tax we pay here on average versus other municipalities. Here are the results:

Compare To They Pay You Pay

Bad News

Richmond

County

$780 $1,900

You pay more than double

Halifax
(Rural)

$1,160 $1,900

You pay almost double

North Sydney

(Downtown)

$2,100 $1,900

Both in CBRM. Both bad news.

Antigonish

(Downtown)

$1,000 $1,900 You pay almost double

"What we're doing in the CBRM, is we're taxing ourselves out of investment. And we're taxing ourselves beyond growth. That's what we're doing" - Rankin MacSween, 2016

CBRM Business Tax Comparison

He then repeated the exercise using a business location instead of a home. Think about a business in North Sydney with an estimated value of $100,000.

Compare To They Pay You Pay

Bad News

Antigonish

$2,600 $5,200

You pay double

"If you want businesses to start, if you want businesses to grow, you have to create a context. You have to create an environment for that to happen." - Rankin MacSween, 2016

What is Rankin's Tax Plan?

Rankin wants to start lowering home and business taxes. He wants to reverse the damage that helps drive us away, and that gets in the way of our potential for growth.

However, you cannot simply lower taxes all at once. So when the tax lowering strategy he proposes begins, he says it will be phased over 4 years of his first term as mayor. This will start moving us in the right direction without disrupting CBRM revenue.

We grow tax revenue by:

  • enabling new people to buy homes for the first time,
  • creating an environment where people will decide to build new homes,
  • making it feasible for families to buy a bigger home as they grow,
  • attracting new businesses, 
  • increasing home values as people decide to make improvements and investments they choose to make, and
  • bringing Cape Breton families back home again, as well as inviting others to live here for the first time.

Those are the kind of decisions people can make when we remove deterrents just like our unreasonable tax rates. We don't want our real estate agents to have to wince whenever they are asked about the annual taxes by a potential buyer.

How Do High Taxes Impact Us?

  • It makes it harder for you to afford a mortgage or buy a more expensive home, or get bank approval.
  • In Halifax and Antigonish, they can buy a house $15,000 to $20,000 more than your $100,000 home, and still pay the same mortgage and tax total each month.
  • The extra $75 or more every homeowner pays in tax, every month, could be spent at local businesses! Spending in our economy creates jobs.
  • When homeowners fall far behind on taxes, the CBRM will sell your home in a tax sale.
  • If you're selling your home, new owners are put off by the high tax rates they will have to pay.
  • For struggling families, every dollar extra they have to pay for tax is another they could be investing in the wellbeing of their family.
  • For families doing well, every dollar extra they have to pay for tax is another they could be investing in their retirement fund.
  • Higher tax rates require landlords to charge higher monthly rent charges to those forced to rent.
  • Delaying home ownership for financial reasons can delay some responsible young couples from starting a family. They are the very roots of our next generation.
  • The tax rates may disincentivize our Western workers from the decision to stay in Cape Breton. They are weary from their travels and time away from family. We cannot give them additional reasons to depart from us.

With child poverty at 42.6% for children 6 and under in the CBRM, can we really afford to take thousands of dollars of food out of their fridge and cupboards?

  • Should they have to have cold nights when the oil runs out?
  • Should they have to be uprooted every time their parent(s) can't pay the rent again?
  • Should they have to go to school ashamed at what their family can't afford to provide, instead of optimistic about learning and playing with their friends?
  • Should they have to endure the burden of seeing their parents slide into a bottle of booze or pills when they can't handle life's challenges?

My questions aren't dramatizations. It's the reality here in the CBRM for many. And with almost half of our youngest children living in poverty, it's almost certain that someone in your family or friends is impacted. Maybe it's you.

Economics is a cold word tossed around by academics. But taking money out of the pockets of families in one of the most struggling municipalities in all of Canada is something we can understand. Be it tax rates, high energy or fuel costs, lack of employment or underemployment, it's a hard go.

It's a hard go that convinces people, it might be time to go.

 

Rankin MacSween wants to remind us about this math, these numbers, and what it means for our wellbeing and our future.

Share this article to your Facebook and turn it into a discussion.

It's the kind of discussion we need to have, don't you agree?

Posted by
Receive news by email and share your news and events for free on goCapeBreton.com
SHOW ME HOW


6,601 7
https://capebreton.lokol.me/next-mayor-rankin-macsween-we-pay-double-the-tax-in-the-cbrm
Gov Election Past Elections Election News & Issues

7

Log In or Sign Up to add a comment.
Depth
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
Rankin has the right ideas and the right path. His vision is right on key and he has the background, experience and education to pull it off. Dealing with core issues brings other issues into reach. Rankin is the only chose for Mayor
Michael MacNeil Follow Me
How much tax does a shipyard in North Sydney downtown pay versus a shipyard in a Marine Industrial Park? Oh wait we don't have a shipyard in the Marine Industrial park to compare. Ok How much tax increase would it take to convince them to follow the CBRM planning Strategy? Oh wait we don't have a real planning strategy.
Ron MacDonald Follow Me
Something has to be done about the CBRM taxes, I moved back to the CBRM from HRM after 20 years there and built a new (modest) house in a rural area, I pay more than double the taxes I paid in HRM and I had a 3 million dollar sports stadium up the road and a hospital across the street in the heart of HRM. When people considering building a new home ask me what the taxes are they immediately change their mind, that needs to change, and the amount of requirements imposed by the CBRM on new subdivisions is absurd, development is at a standstill !. Problem is it takes money to run the CBRM and we have no large commercial tax base (no mines, steel plant..etc). Even small things could help to reduce costs. In HRM there is no heavy garbage pickup, everyone pays to dump at the landfill, green bin pickup is every 2 weeks (except in July/Aug). The building inspection service in CBRM needs fixing, the builder of my home from the mainland quit selling here due to the strict code requirements. Don't plow and salt the roads every time we get a dusting of snow, I have seen the same road plowed 5 times after a storm, buy snowtires! The tax CAP is working for many people given the high tax rates but assessments on older homes are really low and the CAP does nothing for new development, changes need to be made and now. There is not a hope in hell that CBRM will meet the federal waste water requirements, so what happens then? who will be accountable? The tough, unpopular decisions have to be made if the CBRM is to survive long term and get some development happening, I hope who ever is Mayor after this election can do what needs to be done cause right now we are just digging a deeper hole we can't crawl out of!...
Michael MacNeil Follow Me
Ron you have nailed it right on the head. Taxes need to go down ASAP. The CBRM needs to stop trying to be a development agency, they are no good at it. If you want new business and new people lower the taxes and they will come. No need to go to China or hire CEO's. If you really want to try something, put up a few windmills and offer new business cheap green energy. Being the gateway to NFLD we are in the ideal location to supply all Atlantic Canada with fresh vegetables and local products produced here. You just have to fill your grocery cart with fresh vegetables in the winter months to see how much trucking the Atlantic provinces is paying for groceries, and with todays technology there is no need for it .Actually there is no need for any local food banks to be with out fresh vegetables. Time to forget about the steel plants, coal mines and Container terminals, our future depends on a lot of smaller things and most of them are related to high tech and green technology. Make the community attractive and lower taxes and they will come.
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
You both nailed it. Rankin takes keys from PEI...I lived there for a decade and they maintain farming, lower tax rates and draw people in. Downtown charlottetown is a hub, shops, stores, restaurants. They keep infrastructure current, take advantage of the university for business, have vast farming and fishing. They are working on green and tech...including a winter greenhouse attempt. We should be using windcand solar and tidal. We have a smaller populous that could be 100% green in a decade if we dedicated to it. Make the goal for power at Quebec pricing ( less then half ours). Make a goal to reach, and exceed lowering taxes below HRM...we don't have the services as mentioned....make us competitive. We can't draw industry nor population growth by being "higher priced" in every area....power, property tax, water, income tax...why would people move here, stay here. Why would a business set up when costs are double. Cecil Clarke has no interest in growing our economy, he just divys up what we have between a select few. Also why is CBRM paying 100,000 of the ports CEOs salary? Why can't the port pay their own staff, and if not perhaps $200,000 /year for someone with no port background is too much. Drop them to $60,000/year as currently they manage a few cruise ships and 12 staff....you need a good manager not a CEO. Its in the red also so its not like its working
P Sheehan Follow Me
CBRM has to start to crack down on all the owners of buildings that are not being maintained over the whole area . Your real estate values drive your assessments which drives your taxes and far too many of these owners have realized that by letting a property decay they get reduced assessments and reduced taxes. CBRM also has to do some homework and look at the wide variances of assessments as compared to the real selling prices of and in it's commercial districts . CBRM also has to look at the room taxes they collect and where that money goes . That revenue costs them nothing. They just sit there and the money rolls in and the tourist pays them 2% . That could have paid for those flowers eh . or maybe some nice signs to tell you where Sydney really is.
Michael MacNeil Follow Me
I would also suggest that the CBRM and all candidates read Mary Campbell's research on Business Cape Breton. I think this is an unnecessary expense for our Tax Dollars. https://capebreton.lokol.me/extra-extra-the-new-cb-spectator-is-out

Facebook Comments

View all the LATEST
and HOTTEST posts
View

Share this comment by copying the direct link.

  • Our Sponsors

Using this website is subject to the Terms of Use that contain binding contractual terms.