The Pit: 16X9 Documentary on Chris Cline & the Donkin Mine

This investigative piece by Global Television's 16X9 program on the safety record of West Virginia coal baron Chris Cline -- the man who plans to re-open the Donkin Mine -- should be required viewing for all Cape Bretoners.

The similarities between Cape Breton and Appalachia, where Cline was one of the operators blowing the tops off mountains to reach the coal below, are almost eerie.

“They love this place and they need to make a living, so they will work in these mines," a West Virginia woman, much of whose property was destroyed by a Cline operation, told 16X9 reporters.

“Typically, it's a one-horse economy, and that one-horse economy leads to people sort of getting an attitude that they can in fact operate in the fashion that they like to. And since they're driving the jobs in these communities, they can get away with that," a former top U.S. mine inspector says of the typical community in which Cline operates.

The same inspector, who spent years monitoring Cline's operations, was asked if, given Cline's safety violations, Cape Bretoners should worry about the chance of an accident. He said:

"The fact that there's been 92 violations for one mine in two years, for that same kind of basic maintenance problem, coal dust, suggests one ought to be concerned."

The piece is the work of Gil Shochat, Francesca Fionda and Sandra Bartlett. I highly recommend you watch it.

Posted by
Receive news by email and share your news and events for free on goCapeBreton.com
SHOW ME HOW


2,827 7
https://capebreton.lokol.me/the-pit-global-16x9-documentary-on-chris-cline-and-the-donkin-mine
Gov Government News Provincial Government

7

Log In or Sign Up to add a comment.
Depth
[comment deleted] Posted
Ken Greene Follow Me
I agree that the petty feud currently being waged between Kevin Saccery and the various Louisbourg development agencies has to end. Both sides have publicly embarrassed themselves, so let's just call that one a draw...and move on. In the matter of Donkin Mine. The Government of Nova Scotia has weighed in on what they expect from Kameron Coal, in regards to compliance with existing provincial regulations regarding coal mining. You can be assured that reports such as the one broadcast by global will generate knee-jerk reactions, and this is a good thing, as it reinforces the need for prospective employees, the provincial government and the community in general to practice due diligence in this matter. This is just my opinion, but the intelligence exists to identify and resolve safety issues before they create a critical situation. One question in closing. If NSPC is slapped with a carbon tax..who do you think will end up paying it?
[comment deleted] Posted
Ken Greene Follow Me
In hiring Mine Inspectors and engineer(s) qualified to make professional judgments on correct and proper mining practices, the NS Government is doing due diligence. Whether or not this was spawned by the Global Report, this would have had to have been done eventually. In the days of Devco there was a Provincial Department of Mines office in Sydney. At the very least during the last days of Devco, there was an engineer and an inspector there. This is a door that would have opened eventually, because the province would be obliged to police the NS Coal Mines Regulations Act. Even though there has been no underground or submarine mining...or need for a Dept, of Mines office on Cape Breton Island for the last 15 or 16 years, the Coal Mines Regulations Act is still on the books, and it still has to be adhered to. I can tell you as a former employee of Devco who had interaction with Dept. of Mines officials, that if things were not the way they were supposed to be from the standpoint of following provincial regulations, mine operations were suspended. NSPC and the way it is allowed to operate is a joke...a bad one...but a joke. I was told recently by an NSPC field employee, that if we have another ice storm like we had 2 years ago, where I live could be without electricity for 2 weeks. NSPC should still be a provincial crown corporation.
[comment deleted] Posted
[comment deleted] Posted
Ken Greene Follow Me
Michael....Even though we are not dealing with Devco anymore, we are still dealing with the act that governed how Devco practiced mining. Irregardless of your lack of faith in governments past and present, to deal with private sector interests, or to conduct business, the policing of The Coal Mines Regulations Act, and the various acts in place to protect the environment are...or will be...in the hands of Professional Engineers and trained inspectors. Violations of articles in these acts have direct legal consequences because of the physical, and potentially lethal damage that can come from violating them. Unfortunately, laws governing how the province does business don't have the legal teeth they should have. I do get where your going with your Nova Star comment, but I don't think that's the primary issue of concern with the current owner/operator of the Donkin Mine. I'm not defending the owner of Donkin Mine, but in fairness, every heavy industry no matter how tightly regulated, has the potential to generate fatalities. Coal mining on any scale has a higher potential than most. It could be fair to say that every article in the Coal Mines Regulations Act is based on the death of at least one miner.
[comment deleted] Posted
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
Ken Green without a profile photo, I would just like to say that your romantic notion of how the protection regulations were developed, one dead miner at a time, is worthy of a SNL skit, but to be less comical about it, it is not the obvious danger of mining and inevitable deaths that is the point in my mind, but the history of neglecting said regulations which were formed one dead miner at a time that this man has as a personal management resume.
Ken Greene Follow Me
Well Madeline...What I said about The Coal mines regulations Act is sadly true. I find no romance in in the fact that regulations were drafted as instances occurred, and I certainly don't have the audacity to find any part of that even remotely funny, as you obviously do. The history of Coal Mining and Steel production is filled with instances of unscrupulous owners getting rich off the backs and bones of Cape Bretoners. Anyway...my advice to you is simply, do your homework before you weigh in on something so as to save yourself further embarrassment. Honestly...thinking anything to do with miners being killed is funny? Give me a break. Well...that's it for me on this topic.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
you my dear have entirely missed the point. It is not the regulations that are supposed to protect miners that are at question, it is the history of ignoring these regulations.This point you conveniently omitted in your response.
[comment deleted] Posted
Ken Greene Follow Me
Michael...Your original comment popped up on my facebook page. This is because I have recently started following GoCapeBreton.com and have begun looking at the articles posted there. I read your original comment, found it interesting and thought I would reply to it. I worked for Devco for 28 years, and a key part of my job was providing proof to the NS Dept. of Mines that Devco was operating in compliance with regulations. So...there's no conspiracy theory involved in me popping up. I agree with you regarding Westray. This might sound a bit like comparing apples and oranges, but the same thing can be said about drinking and driving...or people texting and driving. Anyway...I've said my piece on this topic, and will move on. Thanks for the chat...oh ...be careful...there is someone reading this thread who thinks miners getting killed is funny. Takes all kinds eh?
[comment deleted] Posted

Facebook Comments

View all the LATEST
and HOTTEST posts
View

Share this comment by copying the direct link.

  • Our Sponsors

Using this website is subject to the Terms of Use that contain binding contractual terms.