Poverty & Un-Civil Politics in CBRM

You never know what type of animal will run in civic politics. In 2014, a seven-year-old canine by the name of Duke The Dogwas elected Mayor of Cormorant, Minnesota. In 2015, Giggles the Pigattempted to run for Mayor in Flynt, Michigan. Then there was Morris the Cat,a mayoralty candidate in Xalapa, Mexico in 2013. Let us not forget, Tiao, the ill-tempered chimpanzee that received 400,000 mayoralty votes in Rio de Janeiro in 1988. Or how about Stubbs the Catthat was elected Mayor of Talkeetna, Alaskain 1977. Closer to home, Tuxedo Stan, a cat from Halifax, was a mayoral candidate in the 2012 municipal elections. 

Just because any dog, cat, pig, or chimpanzee can run civically doesn’t mean they are civil at heart. It does mean, however, that when the common folk get fed up with the status quo, they often come up with creative ways to protest. Dr. Strangejob is neither pig, dog, or chimpanzee, but he does concede that he has often been referred to as a cool-cat.

In follow up to his well past shock and appalled post, Dr. StrangeJob wants to inform all CBRM municipal candidates that he believes that the single most important issue in CBRM is the fact that one in three Cape Breton children live in poverty. For some reason, our politicians (municipal, provincial, and federal) choose not to emphasize this travesty on their way to and from the political trough.

Perhaps the issue of poverty doesn’t make for good photo-ops. Perhaps the issue of poverty is not of concern because the one in three children suffering from poverty are not of voting age. Perhaps it’s because the families suffering in poverty are not in a financial position to contribute to election campaigns. Fortunately, Cape Breton has a few real journalists like Mary Campbell attempting to keep this issue in the forefront. Unfortunately, her efforts are not enough. We must require all CBRM candidates to propose solutions to the issue of poverty in their election platforms. Perhaps a little incentive is necessary.

Dr. StrangeJob is putting CBRM council on notice. Consider the fact that not all un-human candidates in protest-vote election campaigns have been animate objects. There was, for example, the Fire Hydrantthat ran for the Board of Governors at the University of British Columbia but lost by a mere six votes.  Let this be a cautionary tale for CBRM politicians not willing to address the issue of poverty. If you do not address the poverty issue, then your constituents may just find some old dog to run against you – and we all know what old dogs do to fire hydrants. That would just be uncivil.

Dr. StrangeJob

Like Dr. StrangeJob on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/drstrangejob

Follow Dr. StrangeJob on Twitter at https://twitter.com/drstrangejob

Learn more about Dr. StrangeJob at www.drstrangejob.ca

Posted by
Receive news by email and share your news and events for free on goCapeBreton.com
SHOW ME HOW


1,836 36
https://capebreton.lokol.me/un-civil-politics-1
You never know what type of animal will run in civic politics.
Gov Political Commentary

36

Log In or Sign Up to add a comment.
Depth
Christian Murphy Follow Me
I've been pondering the poverty cycle in Cape Breton and asked myself this question. "Have we fallen into poverty or has poverty been imposed upon us?" Governments have become self serving entities and to maintain it's over priced existence has raised taxes, imposed user fees (taxes by any other name) and legislated rules and regulations that burden the average individual. For example, trades people are required to take imposed courses (at a price) in order to work. Obviously good for the schools that were able to make their courses mandatory by law. On one side a person is told to eat healthy when the unhealthy alternatives are all they can afford. While cost of food has continued to rise. We as a community are losing what I call "Food Security" as more and more we depend on sources outside the region and local farming becomes a thing of the past. Energy prices have increased burdening those who can least afford while access to basic communications continues to rise. Financial institutions loan money at compounding rates, money stores and payday loans have commercialized loan sharking while insurance has become an increasing burden. Yet by law people are required to have thus creating "Financial Slavery" as the hungry struggle to stay warm and eat. But these are mere symptoms of the grander disease that is poverty and a fundamental quest for happiness. For some enlightening commentary I strongly suggest watching this TEDTalk by Daniel Kahneman. https://www.ted.com/talks/daniel_kahneman_the_riddle_of_experience_vs_memory?language=en#t-36473
Dan Yakimchuk My Post Follow Me
I believe that poverty is imposed by a group consisting of career politicians, self-serving individuals, and greedy corporations that all have some warped sense of entitlement. I was listening to a local MLA defending their support of Bill 148 by arguing that they were elected to make the “tough decisions”. Bull! That MLA didn’t make any decision other than to vote the way they were told. This is a part of the problem. The solution starts by refusing to admit defeat. My favorite saying is “people change not because they see the light but because they feel the heat”. If you look at what happened in the last federal election, then it becomes clear we can do the same thing regionally. The more light we shine on the issue of poverty, the more hot it is going to get for those in positions to do something about it.
Joe Ward Follow Me
The last thing we need from our representatives is yielding their vote (which *we* gave them) to the higher ups that tell them what to do. This happened recently by the Liberal party in NS, for whom I am a supporter, as they decided to deny a handicapped individual from speaking. The MLAs sheepishly waited to be instructed how to vote and then did so. Unacceptable, neutered behavior.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
it is not accurate to say that the people we elect represent us. With the possible exception of municipal politics, all parties at all levels of government instruct their members on how to vote unless is it the rare designated "free vote". E.May says she won't but we'll have to wait until she has more than her sitting. Yet, we persist in pretending that these politicians are our representatives. This is a lie that helps them to keep the wool over our own eyes. When we elect someone we are giving our power to the party that wins and to the policies it represents. We are out of the picture at that point. Many of bright eyed newbie politicians have discovered what it is to be whipped. So long as the party system is in place, and I don't see it ending soon, we must learn to identify what side of the fence we are on, who is there with us, and who is not, and vote accordingly.
Joe Ward Follow Me
I've found nobody to be standing near my fence. Even those who think they are represented thoroughly by a party often are not on many issues. :) I like the Obamacare example, re: how red state voters hated it, but loved the majority of its provisions if they were asked about them without indicating it was a part of Obamacare. :) Agree with your points though. I think, therefore, we need to tie every bad decision to the legacy of those who just follow party lines like drones. Social will help with that. Maybe it could bring a tiny bit of influence to their background discussions.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
Social WILL help because it is part of the grassroots, and engagement of the grassroots is the solution, although it is long term. Our MLA has tried to embrace social, but is treating it like radio... broadcast only. The people at goCapeBreton know how messy real engagement can be, but it, combined with election reform, will go a long way to a better system.
Joe Ward Follow Me
Well, let's keep at it. :) And perhaps let our MLAs and MPs know when we've had enough of the photo campaigns hanging out with enthusiastic seniors, and we need more substance.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
The power of entitlement is quick appealing. Here's an interesting documentary. Park Avenue: Money Power and the American Dream. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6niWzomA_So
Joe Ward Follow Me
I often use the Monopoly game analogy too. It's very fitting. Even if you start the game on a level playing field (which is not the case, by any means in society), the game ultimately ends. But it ends for *everyone* playing, including the one with the most assets. In a recent experience playing a strategy game for the first time, as a group we discussed the balance of the game. It was important for it to be decision and strategy based without being completely lopsided. So it's one of the lowest level examples I like to use for talking about why regulation is important (progressive taxation, etc). But the regulation should be *cyclical*, not partisan. It should be designed to bring balance and avoid lopsidedness, but to adapt based on current conditions. I.e. Republicans want lower taxes for the corporations (trickle down economic fallacy) Democrats want higher taxes on the rich to pay for social programs and build the middle class (less of a fallacy; middle out economics). And I see neither policy as being correct all the time. Actual policy should change based on economic indicators, not long term discontent that leads to eventual gov leadership change (one party transitions power to another after everyone is fed up -> recent Liberal landslide here in Canada). Related side note: The Grover Norquist pledge (United States, GOP) was one of the most sickening displays of partisan ignorance I've ever heard of: http://www.businessinsider.com/who-is-grover-norquist-pledge-signers-list-fiscal-cliff-republicans-tax-2012-11 I suggest that many of the people in "white trash" trailer parks, ghettos, and the poor barrios are there because their families didn't get centuries of a head start; or in most cases endured that history hobbled by by one form of slavery or another.
Joe Ward Follow Me
On the matter of entitlement: Want to observe local shortsightedness and entitlement by our elected officials? Check out MP Cuzner's playful Xmas poem. The MPs seemed to have lots of fun with it. Did the poem bring any comfort to families who had nothing or very little in their homes in Cape Breton during Xmas? Though I appreciate his good cheer, I think it was best done in his family home or with his personal friends (outside of work). http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/cuzner-commons-night-before-christmas-1.3359484
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
I do agree that it cannot just be survivors, but can be a part. Not just happy successes but how the system failed us, inequality and such. I do agree fresh stories are key and wonder if many would step up...I know I wouldn't have or needed a big nudge back in the day. We have lots of options, and avenues to start this and likely many changes along the way. I do agree that putting a big ol spotlight on it and keeping it there is essential. Its an election time for Cecil but I would expect anything more then lip service and lies about past efforts. The provincial is coming not far after and we have a new PM to push so there is potential
Joe Ward Follow Me
One of the mistakes the CBRM will also make is not thinking of this beyond a statistic. I.e. What could we do to make a 5 or 10% improvement so that we get credit for combating child poverty? However, what they really need to do is contact Community Services, Child Welfare and start learning about what the impact of living in child poverty conditions really can be like. Perhaps the nurses at the Cape Breton Regional Hospital can call the CBRM execs each time a new drug addicted baby is born and has to detox. Those who grow up in poverty often repeat that cycle with their own children. And what advice do we have to give them? If you work hard, you can make your way for you and your children? If we revert to statistics, that may not be the case. At least not here in the CBRM. So my advice is that they get to know what these statistics mean in real world terms. And Community Services would be a great agency to enlighten them. Then they can see directly how important it is to see "opportunity costs" in real life, beyond the press releases. Maybe it will shift their priorities. And maybe one of those priorities will be thus: If you can't answer *this* question now, you had better figure out how to do so, or step aside: "If not the port, then what?" - Mayor Cecil Clarke, 2015
Christian Murphy Follow Me
This statement you made Joe is interesting. "Those who grow up in poverty often repeat that cycle with their own children. And what advice do we have to give them? If you work hard, you can make your way for you and your children?" What people fail to see is how difficult it is to escape poverty. That's why I posted the link to the documentary above and again here. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6niWzomA_So The point is, the "have's" have an unfair advantage over the "have not's" that supports a cycle of poverty. I also posted a link to a TEDTalk that at the end, indicates a rather interesting link between happiness and earnings. This is a rather profound finding. Once people achieve earnings of $60,000 or greater their level of happiness begin to become a near flat line, but under that level of income there is a sharp decline, in short, money can't buy you happiness but a lack of money can certainly cause sadness.
Joe Ward Follow Me
I lost my post by accident, but it started with "Let them eat brioche"! :) tl;dr There is definitely a minimum level of income (regionally adjusted) that can buy basic happiness or well being. Then I pondered why FDR could be born into such wealth and still do the things he did as President of the United States.
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
As a child of poverty in the 80's...when my dad made $7,000 a year and mom was raising 3 kids I can tell you it has deep impact. My dad drank to ease the stress. We were luckier then due to community support and family help but didn't make it easy. Simple things like after Christmas when we got two or three gifts and the "rich" had piles. Then being labelled by schools as "other side of the tracks" or bad news not because of what we did but the economic class we lived in. For me to succeed to took more work just to get opportunity. We all did well because we were brought up to work for everything and no we were at a disadvantage that we had to really push to overcome. We do however appreciate little things more I think. At 9 I robbed freight trains with older family to survive...my preteens I picked blueberries and sold door to door to get school clothes and supplies. We learned that survival was easier as you learned that you did whatever was necessary to live. I became top of my class because I demanded recognition for achuevement and got angry when some were handed it for nothing but fought on. I decided in grade 9 I was going to beat the "upper class" and win class president because I was determined and intelligent and wanted to show the world (well jr high) that I was good enough...so I campaigned to the lower class, as we had the numbers and destroyed the competition...but even then the upper class with help of teachers were given bigger roles for smaller ranks. I defeated that through more determination and demanded my position. My point is when you live in poverty everything is more difficult and I had supportive family...well with words and grit. If I didn't have those I likely wouldn't have done well as many don't and get trapped in the vicious cycle. Sorry all over the board...hope it helps a little from a personal experience post.
Joe Ward Follow Me
When I find myself rooting for the underdog, part of it comes from experiencing what it's like to be the underdog. I appreciate you sharing your experiences. I'm sure you wouldn't trade it if you could. Our uniqueness comes from our experiences.
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
I am not ashamed of where I came from, actually quite opposite. I would not trade it for anything. The experience of learning to stick together, being humble but in taking very calculate risks and digging in and working hard waa priceless life learning. Not wanting the "commercial" side as much and appreciating the little things can not be bought. I see a beggar on the street I ask their story. I am not afraid of much. My family is close. With the struggles came rewards. I as well root for the underdog because I guess I was but didn't submit to it but thrived as just that. Tell me something can't be done and I will show you how it can but with work and time.
Dan Yakimchuk My Post Follow Me
Great story and sharing it helps others understand what we are fighting for. Here is a bit of mine growing up in the Pier. https://drstrangejob.wordpress.com/2015/10/13/mosaic/
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
I wonder if a group got together with stories like ours...mine was a quick version but I mean full, heartfelt ones and lobbied or put together a compilation for governmentand media would it help bring awareness to the current poverty issue? Seems plausible
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
I like the idea. goCapeBreton might be a good host... are you listening goCapeBreton? One question that would have to be answered is the anonymous option, which I don't believe goCapeBreton permits. There are solutions though, like sending a message to someone who could post for the one who is not brave enough to put their name with their story.
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
We would need to gather additional media support. Just for a bigger audience and to demand attention from CBRM, Provincial and Federal elements. Poverty has big negative impact and although my story is successful as others, how many are not...likely a bigger percentage and even successful came with majir struggles that have impact. I had support but I still at times fallen along the way. I was a teen "alcoholic" who drank for social acceptance.I committedcrime for items of stigma or survival (even status items were related to social survival). I used drugs...not just pot but LSD,,and others of a harsher nature. In my late teens and early 20's I focused on success but it was monetary and went into a field I hated but was good at but did redirect my addiction to alcohol and drugs to an addiction for financialgain. Wasn't until mid thirties did I realise that who I was and who I was achieving to be (with no end as the goal waa ultimate success). I am lucky...have no regrets as each hurdle caused growth. My career alliws me know to be able to observe issues and handle them with ease....but at times it hurt especially in the younger days when the battles never ended....sometimes you want that break or are just tired of working 10x as hard as the "well off". Many of my highschool friend are dead...someoverdose, some suicide. Others addicts to this day. Some have mental illness. A few successful or better happy. The data is easily obtained if governmentcared to look. We get "1/3 poverty kids" but what about "this will cause the following". Not much hurts me anymore in a real way but seeing/hearing stories that bring back moments similar to my own past do...because I am from the 70s so why gas it not gotten anywhere near better. Angered that we still have leaders more concerned with subsidizing the Irvings or NSPI but couldn't care less about hungry kids.
Mathew Georghiou Follow Me
The good news is that goCapeBreton.com does have an ANONYMOUS feature that we can turn on. It's currently used in a few select sections where disclosing personal information could be damaging to the person. This includes LOOKING FOR WORK, LOOKING TO RETURN TO CB, MENTORING, INTERNSHIPS, and VOLUNTEERING. If people wanted a section to share their personal stories about poverty (or any other sensitive subject), we can easily and gladly accommodate that.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
great news. I am a community worker from way back but haven't been active in that area here, or anywhere, for years. That time did teach me though that one should network a bit before launching off on a new project. Is there anything like an interagency working group on poverty? Some place where we could link our idea to people who could help make the idea come to life in a most efficient way?
Mary Campbell Follow Me
Part of finding an answer to poverty is talking about it. There is such stigma attached to being poor. I have never been rich and never been truly poor but I've experienced some lean times and one of the greatest stresses was trying to pretend I wasn't broke. It was so refreshing to me to hear Madonna Doucette discuss the realities of being working poor in such a no-nonsense way during her provincial campaign. I liked her honesty the same way I like the honesty in this post, Wayne. Thanks for speaking out.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Mary, may I start with the statement, "I Respectfully Disagree!" The last thing we need is more talking about it and attacking the disease as a community. You can't treat the symptoms you have to attack the disease. Here is the historical data for Christmas Daddies and funds raised. http://www.christmasdaddies.org/index.php/about/amounts_raised Cape Bretoner's contribute greatly to this worthy cause. Probably the highest per capita than anywhere in the the Maritimes. Yet here we sit with the highest child poverty rates. Don't get me wrong, the work of Christmas Daddies and the effort attached is positive however it focuses on the symptom. It's like treating the headache with Tylenol rather than treating the tumor that's about to explode in our head. We have to treat poverty for what it is, a symptom! We as a community have to stop focusing on the symptoms and start addressing the disease. Wayne, you are a rare example, your hard work, perseverance and intelligence allowed you to overcome the economics of poverty. The point is, you are rare. The poor community at large are much less likely to achieve what you have. But there is hope!
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
And I will also say "I respectfully Disagree". Stats don't move people. My feeling is that there are many people who are doing well, or even just making ends meet, who have no idea of the way people are living next to them. When we put a face on it, it sinks in. As an example I point you to the second half of the interview Madonna Doucette did on informorningCB a while back... I'll look for the link in case you missed it.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
http://www.cbc.ca/informationmorningcb/2014/09/29/madonna-doucette---breakfast-biography-5/ Have you heard it? If you have, or after you do now, can you see the value in people with identities speaking like this?
Mary Campbell Follow Me
You may, absolutely, disagree! And I take your point. But I think we need to see stories like Andrew Rankin's profile of a Cape Breton mother trying to raise four sons on $150 a week. http://thechronicleherald.ca/novascotia/1324787-weekend-focus-one-in-3-cape-breton-children-lives-in-poverty To me, that story is not just "talk," it's shining a light on the problem. This morning's CBC interview with Christine Porter of the Ally Centre of Cape Breton was also good. She said they need a mobile clinic for the area -- that's something I can ask my councilor about. I'm a journalist, so my take on this is, obviously, from that perspective.
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
Good banter like this is great. I have no problem with data or stats in general but there does need to be real life faces. People read stats alone and it does not hit hom for the majority. Example: we see stats on animal cruelty...it hurts but gets pushed to the back of the brain.One photo released a few days ago of the old mans dog shot and hung like a prize and people have come out in big numbers. Numerous complaints to Police, SPCA, Animal Cruelty and Natural Resources. Investigation began immediately, autopsy on animal being performed and likely because of the vast outcry in big numbers punishment will be inflicted...dangerous use of firearms maybe, gun ban and removal from the shooter. Anyway my point is real life stories with real life people get a reaction....it draws outcry and forces reaction on the issue. Again stats aren't bad but alone won't bring the masses.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Thus again I will as this question: "Have we fallen into poverty or has it been imposed upon us?" Perhaps the readers could reply with a simple: Fallen or Imposed answer. I would like to know where each of you stand?
Wayne O'Toole Follow Me
Well I think the answer isn't black and white personally. I do agree that povertyis more often that not imposed. In some cases circumstance related but more soimposed and controlled by big business and government. We spend about 15% of the money for income assistance on the poor.Another say 25% on programs with low success rates. The majority is administration. Do you think IA big wigs want to solve the problem? It should, in my opinion be changed to guaranteed income and run federally. I also believe in a combined givernment agency that people walk into and have all options laid out. Now itsa crazy maze of red tape and things not easily found and paperwork and runningaround and rerouted phone calls.
Mathew Georghiou Follow Me
From my experience, if you want to move government to do something about an important issue that they have been ignoring, there are generally two methods: 1. Educate and convince senior politicians and bureaucrats about the issue and how to solve it by reaching out to them directly or through their trusted advisors. This has to be a person-to-person private pitch with the hope that they will empathize/sympathize enough to take action. 2. If the above fails (and it usually does), plan B is public pressure. Pressure that will result in direct and immediate negative consequences to the decision makers. It's sad that this carrot and stick method is needed, but this is what I have learned about politics in Nova Scotia.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
This is crazy: I want to thank Glenn Jessome for sharing this with me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbACCGf6q-c
Christian Murphy Follow Me
For more education on poverty and why. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B4wU9ZnAKAw
Dan Yakimchuk My Post Follow Me
Poverty is both imposed and fallen into, but it is also a vicious cycle. I like the idea of putting a face on CBRM poverty, but not necessarily the face of survivors of the system. Those who survive probably do so in spite of the system. We need to show the suffering of people living in poverty today, rather than give bureaucrats an opening to say that all one needs to rise from the ashes is a bit of hard work and perseverance. I heard a story today of a senior buying a can of tomato soup for his Christmas supper, and another about a single mother of four deciding whether to be hungry, cold, or without medicines this week. This is the reality that some live with, and this is the reality we can use to shame those who can do something about it to do so.
Dan Yakimchuk My Post Follow Me
Just noticed that this post has reached 666 views. This may be a revelation to some, but for CBRM the number of the beast is POVERTY. Here is wisdom, let them that hath no understanding of poverty count fewer votes in the October election and meet the end of their days as politicians. Dr.StrangeJob 12:31:15 Poverty is no laughing matter, but some of our local politicians are. Let’s make 2016 the year to make them accountable or make them history. Happy New Year!

Facebook Comments

View all the LATEST
and HOTTEST posts
View

Share this comment by copying the direct link.

  • Our Sponsors

Using this website is subject to the Terms of Use that contain binding contractual terms.