Welcoming Immigrant Entrepreneurs

OPINION: Dannie Brown 

The recent attention that the world has given to the Syrian outmigration of thousands and thousands of people has catapulted the discussion of who these emigrants are, and just what background and experience might they be bringing with them to our country — if we take in any.

It's not unreasonable to be concerned on some level about the security surrounding this many people who are on the move, and I applaud any government that is at least acknowledging this possibility.  That being said, and moving beyond that issue, I'd say: "Let's not look a gift horse in the mouth."

United States' research shows that immigrants are almost twice as likely to start businesses, as are native-born Americans. In fact, immigrants have been consistently more entrepreneurial than those who were native-born. In 2010, more than 40 per cent of the Fortune 500 companies were founded by an immigrant or the child of an immigrant. Staying in the U.S., immigrant-founded engineering and technology firms employed approximately 560,000 workers and generated $63bn in sales in 2012. That being said, there still exist many barriers for immigrants to bring their entrepreneurial ideas to reality in the U.S. A similar problem exists in Canada.

A second "gift horse," if you will, is found in the many international students who come to Canada every year to study abroad. Canada's birth rates are declining. Canada's immigration applications are backlogged for years. Our economy is lethargic at best, and facing new challenges from falling oil prices. However, on Jan. 1, 2015, new federal rules introduced by the Canadian government, "no longer give international students with Canadian work experience an automatic leg-up" when applying to stay in Canada permanently. The Canadian government said that in 2008, approximately $6.5bn was determined to be the approximate amount that international students contributed to the Canadian economy. Yang Xinyu, of the China Scholarship Council, reported that in the same year, some 180,000 post-secondary students left China to study at a college or university in another country — including Canada, but that less than 40 per cent of them returned to China upon completing their studies.

Entrepreneurship and innovation are critical to community economic development. They generate jobs, increase wages and the standard of living. In these times of youth outmigration from our province and a declining and aging population, it seems rather obvious that all levels of government need to work together to do whatever they can, as quickly as they can, to help potential entrepreneurs settle anywhere in Canada, especially in the Atlantic provinces, and begin contributing to our economic growth. Approximately 2,500 immigrants settle in Nova Scotia each year; the struggle we face is trying to keep all of them here. With high taxes and worn-out attitudes towards immigrants, many will find their way to larger, more multicultural, centres like Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver.

Dannie Brown is assistant professor of organizational management in the Shannon School of Business at Cape Breton University. He is writing in a personal capacity.

[email protected]

@DannieDBA on Twitter

What do you think? Share your thoughts below. 

Posted by
Receive news by email and share your news and events for free on goCapeBreton.com
SHOW ME HOW


2,004 20
https://capebreton.lokol.me/welcoming-immigrant-entrepreneurs
Dannie Brown shares his thoughts on the power of immigration to drive social and economic change.
Gov Political Commentary Living Newcomers Challenges People Blogs & Opinions

20

Log In or Sign Up to add a comment.
Depth
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
I just happened to post something on this on my FB feed earlier today... it was: "I talked with a young, educated "immigrant" to CB I ran into at the mall today. He is not actually an immigrant... born in Montreal, but he "looks like an immigrant"... most people would call him "ethnic", polite people that is. He is leaving. He says most of the "not from here" young professionals are not staying. Smarten up Cape Breton!" I felt that he was not just talking about racism, but perhaps unworldliness too, and maybe the unwelcoming atmosphere. We are very friendly... hi how ya doing... but we don't really welcome newcomers or diversity. I also sensed that the more fundamental thing for him was a lack of opportunities for educated youth without work experience. That said, I don't think we should mix the concept of refugee with the concept of economic immigrant. But either way they come, we have to figure out why they don't stay. It may be similar to why our own young don't stay.
Joe Ward Follow Me
With our own out migration, I think it's fairly straightforward. It's a lack of opportunity. I certainly would never be surprised if our immigrants decided they wanted to be in better Canadian markets with more opportunity. If they come to start a new life, they probably don't want to move into a region with such big challenges. While they may quickly develop a love for our country, and embrace all the opportunities it provides, they have no inherent regional patriotism like that of the people who grew up here. But overall, *if* we can recruit them to come and to stay here, it's very beneficial. They see this place entirely with fresh eyes, and an optimism about what's possible.
Richard Lorway Follow Me
This is good information, Madeline. We need to have these kinds of conversations and speak frankly if we hope to address the demographic challenges we are facing. Ultimately, our community's survival depends upon us solving this problem.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Hi Madeline, I would like to address your statement, "Smarten up Cape Breton!" I felt that he was not just talking about racism, but perhaps unworldliness too, and maybe the unwelcoming atmosphere. We are very friendly... hi how ya doing... but we don't really welcome newcomers or diversity." I have lived in other parts of Canada, and to be quite honest, the big cities are not all that welcoming either, in fact, I would say they are less so. I don't see this as the issue, it's a fundamental truth, there are no options, or opportunity for young people so the leave. If we focus on supporting local entrepreneurs, they will create job opportunities and will find people willing to work here if we compete (pay) what people are getting paid in other regions of Canada. It has nothing to do with not being nice enough, it's about offering opportunity. We spend so much time discussing the state of the forest while investing very little in planting indigenous trees.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
I have had a different experience, and have heard comments from others along my experience lines. Non of this is scientific, but when you bring a doctor's wife to rural white cape breton, it is not easy for her to fit in or be truly welcomed, and if she isn't happy, the couple isn't happy. I don't think that any of this, although true, goes against your feelings that we need to support local entrepreneurs. I agree with your position on that. We need their businesses, but we also need doctors.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
No point in looking for doctors if the tax base to support them doesn't exist. I will not say you are wrong, I am simply saying that not everywhere in Canada is going to accept people personally with open arms. Like all things, respect and friendship are earned. It may simply be a little harder in Cape Breton, but I truly doubt it. Expectations are tough, trust me, I drown in my own everyday! 8-)
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
ask people from here who have been gone for a while about how it takes 10 years to fit in, unless you have kids who are still at an age that will help. I was more Cuban after two years in Cuba than I was a caper until most of a decade has passed. It is just one segment of our society, but Cape Breton is know by many middle-aged professionals to be a hard nut to crack, socially. I know people who have told me the same thing, comparing other places they have lived to here. Yes, we were all younger in those other places, but some people came here at the age I was when I went to other places. I know it takes time, now that I have put my decade in, but it takes longer here, and the irony is that we think ourselves a friendly and welcoming place.
Rory Andrews Follow Me
One reason for this is we don't have a very transient population. When I was teaching overseas in China, fellow teachers rarely stayed in Asia over a year or two, so people made friends incredibly quickly to deal with the social isolation of living in a city of 25 million people. Why would people call someone new on Friday night when they can call the same person they've called for 25 years? When faces don't change, people don't value new ones. Also, people here always ask me if I'm from here, and when I say yes, I see them visibly relax. I haven't lived in Cape Breton for 20 years, but because I spent my first 9 years on Rigby Road, somehow that proves I'm not a cannibalistic madman. I still don't fully understand that mentality, but I've been trying to wrap my head around it for a while now.
madeline yakimchuk Follow Me
very good observation!
Joe Ward Follow Me
Is the blending challenging because the type of person coming here is now different than the historical archetype of a family living here? "Professionals" versus blue collar heritage. The stuffy ones are no fun at the kitchen parties says one side, and the other side thinks there is too much alcoholism at kitchen parties. Yada yada. :P
[comment deleted] Posted
Joe Ward Follow Me
Are non-permanent residents prohibited from entering, or you did enter with eligibility but felt that someone inferior was selected? In terms of poster child, it's interesting that our International students are always utilized directly on "posters" in terms of the marketing collateral for CBU. I'm very surprised to hear that you feel there is a disparity there. That's definitely not what I would have expected to hear.
[comment deleted] Posted
Joe Ward Follow Me
People will try to call it "sour grapes" in order to pigeonhole you. Don't let that happen. I have it attempted on me by some very intelligent people frequently enough to be of note. Don't let them use logical fallacy to distract from the real issues. They often do that to distract from your position or to get you to react in such away that we skew the focus ourselves. Fighting against bias and unfairness is hard, but we must do so. Of course, we also have to protect our best interest and careers too. And reluctantly, we all end up sitting on info that should be out there, myself included. It's a very tough trade off.
Mathew Georghiou Follow Me
Thanks for sharing Marian. If it's any consolation (I doubt it :-), many Cape Bretoners don't want other Cape Bretoners to succeed too much either (regardless of if they are from here or CFAs). We are our own worst enemy in all sorts of ways.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Great points Marian, ironically, the barriers you mentioned are there for everyone and impact us all from our personal perspective. The best places in the world to live if you're an entrepreneur do not include Cape Breton. It's simple, the investment capital available is so small that only a very few will ever achieve success. Yes, we will see those who do succeed paraded around the local media with the political caption "Look what we achieved" when in fact,it was fundamentally a drop in the proverbial bucket of what is needed or has been invested in and or given to those who are already established and quite likely have a net worth in excess of $500K. This is not a complaint, it is simply the reality.
[comment deleted] Posted
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Ya, I find myself laughing too much at all of this; a state of apathetic hysteria. Marian, I will say I retract my statement regarding indigenous trees, since you're already here, I think some new genes won't hurt the pool! Perhaps will simply need trees! I would like to request coconut trees!
[comment deleted] Posted
[comment deleted] Posted
Joe Ward Follow Me
I lived in Tampa outskirts (Land O Lakes/Lutz) from 2009 to 2014. Love it there. ;)
Christian Murphy Follow Me
Ask and you shall receive, seems I have been granted my request! I suspect I would qualify as a white spruce!
Christian Murphy Follow Me
When there is a societal push towards a specific agenda it is often at the expense of some other less politically popular agenda. To Richard's point, it is probably up to us to fix it. All too often we (Cape Bretoners) have a belief that the Government will fix the situation, myself included. The reality is that Governments have not succeeded. This has been demonstrated in multiple posts on this site. In fact, this is the "Branch Plant" approach only in this instance, applied to immigration. Where are all the branch plants? If foresee, that once the government money runs out we will be asking, where are all the immigrants. This agenda will ultimately create a situation that will direct limited resources away from where they are needed, supporting local entrepreneurs who have the commitment and will to be in Cape Breton. So to Professor Brown's statistics, they are true from a national perspective. Immigration will spur economic benefit, however, it is my belief that Cape Breton will not reap the rewards. So let's calculate the cost of bringing in and supporting an immigrant entrepreneur and put an equal amount of capital in the hands of a local entrepreneur with export potential, or not. Locals are a lot less news worthy I suspect.
Joe Ward Follow Me
I don't think Federal support of immigration programs will have any direct impact on investment in our business community. Those sources should be pulling from different pools. However, I do think there are going to be challenges maintaining people who want to live here, immigrants making the same type of evaluation of what to do and where to go as those who are current longtime residents.
Christian Murphy Follow Me
The outward migration continues. I just posted this as a separate item. Wake Up Call: McKenna Sends Urgent Message read what he says.....the same rhetoric we've been reading for years and still the same results. It's hilarious if you ask me! How many times can I read the same recycled BS spewing from a different mouth!

Facebook Comments

View all the LATEST
and HOTTEST posts
View

Share this comment by copying the direct link.

  • Our Sponsors

Using this website is subject to the Terms of Use that contain binding contractual terms.